"It was a dream 15 years ago," Steve Buresh said in the Facebook video announcing that his Plainfield bakeshops would close, as Patch reported in May. "I said, 'You know what? I'm going to give it my all,' and I did."
This is Plainfield's first Thanksgiving in years without the Cheesecake Store at 14210 Lincoln Highway or its sister Cookie Store across the lot. Those cheesecakes have been part of a lot of holiday tables. In 2024, the Herald-News reported that the bakery made about 30 cheesecakes a day, more around the holidays, and needed extra refrigeration just to handle seasonal orders.
The bakers stepping in are following his path. Buresh built his business at the Plainfield farmers market before he ever had a storefront. Two of the new names in town come from that same small-batch, market-table world, and a downtown coffee house that started the same way connects them.
How Plainfield's Cheesecake Store Started
Buresh began selling desserts at Plainfield's farmers market in 2011 and opened the Cheesecake Store in 2014, according to Patch. He ran an Oswego location from 2017 until it closed in 2022. In November 2024 he opened a second Plainfield concept, the Cookie Store, partly to centralize baking for both shops in a bigger space.
That expansion lasted about a year and a half. By the first week of May 2026, the Cookie Store had served its last treat. A few days later, Buresh said the Cheesecake Store and Sandwich Shop would close too. He pointed to the economy and high food costs, and told Patch that April had been the business's slowest month since the pandemic. "The time is now to close up the Cheesecake Store, too, and start the second half of my life," he said.
That left two buildings at 143rd Street and Lincoln Highway, one of which had been set up to bake for a whole business, and a market-to-storefront success story without a successor.
The Cookie Store Building Is a Patisserie Now
The successor showed up in the Cookie Store building itself. KREMA Patisserie opened Sept. 28 at 14220 US-30, the former Steve Buresh's Cookie Store, and Patch reported it comes from the team behind Krema Coffee House. The Herald-News reported that the bakery sold out on its first day.
The Krema story follows the same path as Buresh's. Krema Coffee House opened in downtown Plainfield in late 2017 and has since added locations in Lockport, Tinley Park and North Aurora. The downtown shop at 24038 W. Lockport St. is still the original.
For holiday planning, here's what matters. The patisserie's Facebook page describes "Chef Mitchell's passion for baking" turned into "handcrafted croissants, bagels, breads, pies, pastries & desserts." The owners' opening note pitched it as a spot to "be the office hero with a box of fresh croissants" or "bring home a loaf of freshly baked sourdough." That covers the bread basket, the dessert table and breakfast for the guests sleeping in your basement.
The hours are early and short. KREMA Patisserie is open 6 a.m. to 3 p.m. Monday through Friday and 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. on weekends. A shop that sold out on its first day and closes mid-afternoon is a morning stop. If you're counting on a pie or a loaf for Thursday, Nov. 26, call or message the shop well before the holiday week about orders.
Two Market Bakers Head Downtown
The second new bakery repeats the market-to-storefront path even more closely, with two bakers instead of one.
Plainfield Bakehouse, at 24042 Lockport St., Suite 100 in historic downtown, is a partnership between Plainfield native Kim Wisehunt, owner of Blue Heron Bagels in Shorewood, and Plainfield resident Michaela Gallaher, owner of Gallaher Sourdough. In October, the Herald-News reported November as the projected opening.
Both bakers started small, much like Buresh did:
- Blue Heron Bagels was a home-kitchen cottage-food microbakery in Shorewood in 2025, selling hand-crafted sourdough bagels online and at local markets. It offered Friday porch pickup, according to a 2025 Herald-News profile.
- Gallaher Sourdough sold organic sourdough loaves on Fridays at Blackberry Lane Farmstand in Channahon in 2025, first come, first served, according to the Morris Herald-News.
The Bakehouse's own site lists authentic bagels, organic sourdough breads, cookies, muffins and pizza crusts. It also plans to stock used books, art, nostalgic candy, "things that make you think of Plainfield," and a Bakehouse Blend from Krema Coffee.
The Krema blend connects the two new bakeries. The Bakehouse is also on the same downtown stretch of Lockport Street as Krema Coffee House, which is at 24038 W. Lockport St. The Route 30 lot that used to be Buresh's now carries the Krema name, and the downtown bakery is pouring Krema coffee.
Woodman's Handles the Rest of the List
Pies and sourdough are only part of Thanksgiving. Butter, cream cheese and a turkey are the rest, and that changed this fall too.
Woodman's Food Market opened Sept. 29 at Illinois Route 59 and 119th Street, a 243,500-square-foot store, as the Herald-News reported. Before that, the closest Woodman's was in North Aurora. Mayor John Argoudelis called it "one of the Midwest's great grocers" in the Herald-News's grand opening coverage.
If you shopped elsewhere until this fall, a few details are worth knowing before Thanksgiving week:
| What | Woodman's Plainfield |
|---|---|
| Regular store hours | Open 24 hours |
| Thanksgiving Day | Closes at 2 p.m., reopens 6 a.m. Friday |
| Payment | Cash, PIN debit, Discover, WIC, Quest/EBT |
| Checks | Not accepted at Plainfield |
| Gas station, Thanksgiving | 8 a.m. to 1:45 p.m.; pumps take PIN debit or Discover around the clock |
The payment row matters most. Discover is the only credit card Woodman's accepts, according to its FAQ, so bring a debit card or cash if Visa or Mastercard is what you normally use. The 2 p.m. Thanksgiving close also matters if you tend to make a last-minute run while the turkey rests. The store page has current hours.
Your Holiday Week, Mapped
Put together, Plainfield's holiday food stops are now in three places: Route 30 for pastry, Lockport Street downtown for bread and coffee, and Route 59 for the big grocery run. A workable week looks like this:
- Early in the week: Stop at KREMA Patisserie, 14220 US-30, before the 3 p.m. close, and ask about holiday orders.
- Midweek: Do the big shop at Woodman's, Route 59 and 119th, with debit, cash or Discover.
- Thanksgiving morning: Any last Woodman's run has to be done before the 2 p.m. close.
- Saturday, Nov. 28: Spend the evening downtown.
That Saturday is busy downtown. Grinchmas on the Green runs 4:30 to 7:30 p.m. at Village Green, with free hot cocoa and cookies under the pavilion at 4:30 while supplies last. Santa and the Grinch arrive with help from the Plainfield Fire Protection District at 5:00 and light the giant Village Green tree at 5:15, according to the Plainfield Park District. The same evening, the Plainfield Area Public Library's Handmade Holiday Market runs 5:00 to 8:00 p.m. at 15025 S. Illinois St. with 50 vendors and free admission. Krema Coffee House is on Lockport Street, close enough for a warm drink between the tree lighting and the market.
Two days later, on Monday, Nov. 30, the Village of Plainfield's calendar lists the Sparkle in the Park Tree Lighting at Settlers' Park, 24403 W. Lockport St., from 5:00 to 8:00 p.m. It includes musical performances, an ice-carving demonstration, a 3-D lighting display, carolers, a holiday touch-a-truck and food trucks.
If you're planning holiday hosting around a move, or a move around the holidays, I'm happy to share which Plainfield bakeries and shops make good welcome gifts and what that first week in a new house usually looks like. Stephanie Staneart knows these streets well, from Route 30 to Lockport Street. Schedule Your Free Consultation and let's talk through your timeline.